The tragic death of a 7-year-old girl, Kim Ha-neul, who was fatally stabbed by her teacher at an elementary school in Daejeon, has underscored the urgent need for a national framework to address mental health support for educators in South Korea. The incident, which occurred earlier this week, has raised concerns about the lack of effective mental health management and legal protections for teachers.
The teacher involved had reportedly shown signs of depression and had exhibited aggressive behavior towards a colleague prior to the attack. These warning signs have led to speculations that mental health issues may have played a role in the tragedy. However, experts caution against hastily attributing the attack to depression alone, emphasizing that such an approach could further stigmatize those living with mental health conditions.
Lack of Legal Protections for Teachers with Mental Health Issues
Despite the teacher’s history of mental health struggles, there are no legal provisions or enforcement measures in place to prevent teachers with mental health conditions from interacting with students. According to education sector sources, there are no protocols to separate educators showing signs of mental distress from their students, either during the hiring process or throughout their tenure.
The teacher involved in the stabbing had taken a six-month medical leave for depression in December 2024 but returned to work just 20 days later after submitting a hospital note. Under current regulations, teachers on medical leave can resume their duties by submitting a doctor’s note, without further evaluation.
Reports indicate that the teacher had also shown violent tendencies, including an altercation with a colleague just four days before the incident and damaging a school computer the day before the stabbing. Although the incidents were reported to the Daejeon Metropolitan City Office of Education, no immediate action was taken, and the tragedy followed shortly thereafter.
Experts Call for Greater Mental Health Oversight
Paik Jong-woo, a professor of psychiatry at Kyung Hee University College of Medicine, expressed concern over the lack of action taken after reports of the teacher’s violent behavior. Paik emphasized the need for a qualified psychiatric assessment, which could have potentially prevented the incident.
“There is a significant sense of regret over whether the outcome could have been different if a proper mental health assessment had been conducted,” said Paik.
Despite the existence of committees within provincial and metropolitan education offices to assess the fitness of teachers with mental health conditions to continue their duties, experts argue that these committees have largely been ineffective. In Daejeon, the committee has not reviewed any cases in the past two years, and similar gaps exist within other regions, including Seoul.
Growing Mental Health Crisis Among Educators
Recent data highlights a worsening mental health crisis among educators. In 2023, nearly 10,000 teachers and other elementary school staffers sought treatment for depression, with the rate of treatment more than doubling since 2018. According to figures submitted by Rep. Jin Sun-mee of the Democratic Party of Korea, the number of teachers receiving treatment for depression in 2023 was 37.2 per 1,000 workers, up from 16.4 per 1,000 in 2018.
This rising trend has prompted calls for a more comprehensive approach to mental health management for teachers, including the integration of mental health specialists into the school system.
The Need for Systemic Change
Paik emphasized that mental health issues in schools should not be viewed solely as a school-level problem but as a broader societal issue. Schools, he argued, need better systems in place to seek assistance from mental health professionals to address the mental well-being of their staff.
However, experts also caution against oversimplifying the connection between mental health and violent behavior. While depression may have played a role in the tragic event, experts point out that depression is typically associated with self-harm rather than aggression toward others.
“Depression is often a self-destructive condition. Most individuals suffering from depression are more likely to harm themselves than others,” Paik noted. He warned against using depression as a scapegoat for violent actions, as this could reinforce harmful stereotypes and deter individuals from seeking the help they need.
The Daejeon stabbing has now sparked widespread calls for a national-level approach to mental health in the educational sector, urging the government to take action before another tragedy occurs.
Related Topics
